What Can Game Theory Teach Us About Real Estate Negotiation?

Game theory, in essence, is the study of how people make decisions in strategic situations, where the outcome depends not only on their own actions but also on the actions of others.  

At first glance, you might wonder, “How is this relevant to real estate?” As it turns out, the art of property negotiation can involve many of the same principles. Game theory can offer a fascinating lens through which both buyers and sellers might enhance their negotiation skills.  

In this article, we’ll explore some simple game theory concepts and discuss how they apply to real estate.  

1. Informational Asymmetries 

Informational asymmetry occurs when one party has more (or better) information than the other. In the realm of real estate, this is a crucial concept that can have profound implications. 

To better understand why, let’s imagine a few hypotheticals: 

Example 1: A homeowner knows about a potential zoning change that would allow a new high-rise next door, potentially obstructing the view. A buyer might value the property for its current ocean view, unaware of the pending change. The seller, having more information, could potentially capitalize on this by selling at a higher price before the zoning change becomes public knowledge. 

Example 2: Consider a situation where a property has a hidden defect like a foundation issue. The seller, aware of the problem, may try to push for a quick sale without disclosing this detail. A buyer, unaware of the problem, might assume they’re getting a bargain due to the reduced price. 

Example 3: A neighbourhood might be slated for significant infrastructure upgrades, like a new train station. Sellers who are aware might hold off on selling or raise their prices, knowing that property values are likely to increase. Uninformed buyers might unknowingly purchase at this elevated price, not realizing the current premium is based on future expectations. 

Furthermore, while withholding critical information about a property might provide short-term gains, it may also lead to long-term repercussions – legal or otherwise. So, while understanding and leveraging informational asymmetries can be important, maintaining transparency and ethical standards is equally crucial for sustained success. 

2. The Bigger Picture 

Game theory also underscores the importance of understanding broader motivations and competing factors. In real estate, these are heavily influenced by knowledge of the broader market conditions:  

Example 1 – Seller’s Market: Properties are in short supply, and demand is high. Sellers know they’re in a favorable position, which can lead to higher prices and less willingness to negotiate. As a buyer, you are aware of the increased competition, and might increase your tolerance for having to pay above asking price.  

Example 2 – Buyer’s Market: The tables turn. Properties are plentiful, and sellers might be motivated to negotiate and close deals faster, even if it means reducing the price. As a buyer, you have an enhanced ability to negotiate a lower price and may even be more likely to walk away from certain negotiations.  

3. Use of strategy 

Understanding motivations revealed in conversation can also be pivotal: 

Example 1: Suppose a buyer learns that a seller has already bought another property and is paying two mortgages. Knowing this, the buyer might feel they have the upper hand in negotiations, believing the seller is motivated to finalize the sale quickly to ease their financial burden. 

Example 2: An investor is looking to purchase multiple properties in a particular area to develop an apartment complex. If sellers become aware of this, they might collaborate to hold out for higher prices, recognizing that the investor is likely to pay more given the potential future gains from the development project. 

Example 3: If a buyer recognises that a property has been passed in at auction and didn’t sell, they might approach the seller post-auction with a lower offer, predicting that the seller’s motivation to sell might be higher after the disappointment of a failed auction. 

Strategic insights gleaned from research or conversations with sellers and agents can be game-changing, but every revelation or concealed piece of information is a double-edged sword. For instance, if a buyer openly shares their intent to buy multiple properties for a project, this could prompt sellers to demand higher prices, anticipating future development gains. But conversely, this revelation might lead to bulk deal offers from sellers eager to cash in quickly. It’s essential to weigh the pros and cons of revealing intentions. Sometimes, keeping your cards close to your chest can be beneficial, while in other scenarios, showing your hand might open doors to unexpected opportunities. 

Hopefully these small examples have helped you to better understand the role that game theory can play in real estate. Game theory offers profound insights into the dynamics of negotiation, underscoring the incredible value of information, and the pitfalls of sometimes revealing too much or too little.  

It all illustrates just how vital a deep understanding of the property, market and other parties can be. With careful planning, extensive research, and the help of an experienced buyers’ agent, you can ensure that you’re always maximising your outcomes from real estate negotiation.  

Want to discuss this further?

For expert guidance in property strategyy, and what it could mean for you as a property investor, book in for a free consultation to make informed decisions, tailored to your investment goals. Don’t let affordability challenges hinder your success. Act now with Search Party Property!